Ranked by Bloomberg as the best mail-order pecan pie in the world, Goode Brazos Bottom Pecan Pie is a genuine, authentic Texan dessert that everyone should try at least once!
Gooier than the rest and made with real Brazos Valley pecans and farm-fresh eggs, it's made on a family recipe that’s been passed down through the generations.
If you’re new to Goode Co. Shop and our Texas pecan pie, then here’s a closer look at what makes it so beloved:
Why Our Brazos Bottom Pecan Pie Stands Apart
Voted Best By Bloomberg
Leading news, culture, and tech company ‘Bloomberg’ recently tried dozens of the best mail-order pecan pies. Our Brazos, Texas, Pecan Pie was voted number one by their team. Here’s what they had to say:
“This pie is going into my dessert hall of fame. The nuts are perfection, toasted crisp to both enhance their sweetness and keep them from falling into that soggy pecan pie vortex. There’s a generous amount of buttery custard, rich in brown sugar. The crust holds up just long enough to contain the pie, then melts in your mouth.”
“Definitely one of the best pecan pies I’ve ever had, and I’ve had many.” “I would lick this off the floor. Custardy. Crunchy. Perfect.”
Texas Pecan from the Brazos Valley
As the name suggests, we source our pecans directly from the Brazos River region of Texas.
Here, the warm climate and rich river-bottom soils create incredibly flavorful pecans that are perfect for pecan pies! So much so that our pie has become synonymous with the valley’s pecans and is highly sought after. You can’t get more authentically Texan than that.
Gooier Than The Rest, Thanks to a Family Recipe
Our pies are reviewed as being more gooey and richer in flavor than the rest! But how?
The story behind the Brazos Bottom Pecan Pie Goode Co. Shop is built on traditions dating back to the 1970s, when Jim Goode launched Goode Co.’s first barbeque restaurant.
Over the years, we developed a Texas pecan pie recipe that wowed visitors from across the Houston area. It soon became a must-have for weekend dates, birthday parties, barbeque takeouts, and eventually, Goode Co. Shop orders.
We trust our community’s taste more than anyone else's, so when it started working, we stuck with our recipe!
The Wooden Box.
Our wooden box is our tribute to Texas, and the pie is the icing on the cake. Knowing that our Texas pecan pies are often chosen for special occasions and gifts, they serve as souvenirs of the day, each branded with Texan-themed or custom messages.
It also keeps the pie fresh and protected during transit and home storage, so it looks as good on your dinner table as it did the day it left our ovens!
What to Look for in The Best Mail-Order Pecan Pies
Here’s a rundown of the qualities you need to look for in any great pecan pie:
Texture and Filling
In our opinion, the difference between a good and unforgettable pecan pie is in the filling and texture.
It must be smooth and gooey to provide that soft, gorgeous balance. Anything less and it’ll be dry and boring. Anything more and it becomes a rubbery or runny mess.
Look for a mail-order pecan pie with a thick gooeyness in the pictures, with a healthy dose of yummy pecans on top!
Local Sourcing of Ingredients
It’s easy to throw together a ‘pecan pie’ with cheap, store-bought ingredients. But it’ll be disappointing.
That’s why we use locally sourced Brazos beacons that have been enriched by the river’s soil and nutrients, giving them that richer, nuttier taste.
We also recommend looking for a pie that uses farm-fresh eggs, which will give it extra flavor and that essential smooth gooeyness.
The Crust
The crust must be flaky and buttery to contrast with the sweet filling and keep it sturdy. We handcraft our crusts for that result, baking them carefully for a better crunch. Our secret is taking our time, never rushing the baking process.
Packaging
The best mail-order pecan pies need careful packaging, too. Without a secure box, there’s a real chance you receive nothing more than a big SPLAT of gooey pecans.
That’s why we always deliver in a secure Texan wooden box. So, the pie survives the trip from both physical and heat damage. And it arrives gift-ready.
Reputation
While we wouldn’t want to rule out newcomers to the Pecan pie game, there’s something to be said for trusted pies. If you want to ensure your money is well spent, look for a pie that is highly rated and reviewed. Such as the Number One ranking of our Goode Co. Shop Brazos Bottom Pecan Pie received from Bloomberg!
How to Order Pecan Pie Online from Goode Co. Shop
Shipping options and delivery
Ordering our famous Goode Co. Shop pecan pie is easy via our online shop. We also have a chocolate bourbon pecan pie twist on the classic!
We ship our pies out Monday through Friday, including with FedEx Ground or Home Delivery. For delivery outside Texas, we offer FedEx 2nd Day Shipping to protect the pie’s quality during the warmer months.
- We may also have some Goode Company promo codes available here.
- Read more about our shipping information.
Can you freeze a mail-order pecan pie?
Yes, you can freeze our mail-order pecan pies for around 4 months from the ship date. It’ll remain rich in flavor and gooey upon defrosting.
Gift options and packaging
You can order our Brazos Pecan Pie in a variety of wooden gift boxes or our cheaper cardboard delivery box. The box is carefully designed to prevent slipping during transit, making it perfect for gifting anywhere in the US!
Frequently Asked Questions About Mail-Order Pecan Pie
What are common pecan pie mistakes?
The most common mistake is found in the filling. Using old, cheap pecans that aren’t fresh results in bitter, bland, or even rancid flavoring. You can also mess up the gooeyness if you overfill the pie dish and bake it unevenly.
Do Goode Co. pecan pies need to be refrigerated?
No, our pies have a shelf life of around 3 weeks at room temperature. You can fridge it for about 3 months or freeze it for about 4 months, too.
Why does my pecan pie separate?
If you’ve been making your own pecan pie and it's been separating, it’s probably because the filling wasn’t properly mixed before baking. To avoid that, you need to mix it smoothly while preventing foaming. You may also have overfilled it or baked it too long.
What is a poor man's pecan pie?
A poor man’s pecan pie is the name given to the budget version of the pie. They taste of pecans, but often don’t use them at all, use oatmeal, or cheap pecans that pale in comparison to locally sourced nuts like Brazos Bottom pecans.
Order Your Authentic Texan Pecan Pie Today!
Ordering a truly Texan, ultra gooey, and irresistible pecan pie is easy with Goode Co. Shop. Feel free to make an order today with your choice of Brazos Bottom Pecan Pie in wooden boxes.